Holy carp! This is a great, amazing, terrific, superlative-worthy game! There’s been a lot of buzz about Fiasco lately, and I can definitively say that it if well-deserved. I played a game at GenCon which was quite good. It was certainly good enough to make me want to play again. Last weekend, though, we played a game of Fiasco using the playset I just wrote, The Jersey Side. This game was amazing. It was, straight up, like a Coen brothers film, or as one of the players described it, an Elmore Leonard story. It was insanely fantastic and left me hankering for more.
Why was this one better than the game at GenCon? There are a couple of reasons, I think. I played at GenCon with Steve Segedy and three guys I didn’t know. While all these guys were great players, I think we weren’t as much on the same page. My home group consisted of my wife Krista, Jared Axelrod, and J.R. Blackwell. These are folks I know very well, and we had a strong rapport and really trusted each other.
Also, at GenCon we played the Touring Rock Band playset. This is amusing and a bit debauched, but there was more humor and showbiz superficiality going on in that one. The Jersey Side arose from a conversation I had with Kenneth Hite and Jason Morningstar at Origins. Ken was bragging about Chicago’s legendary corruption, and I pish-poshed him by saying I was from New Jersey. I don’t know if you remember, but there was a big organ smuggling scandal in New Jersey last year, involving over 40 arrests, including rabbis and local politicians. I suggested I should do a Fiasco playset based on the scandal, and Jason agreed.
Since I just finished up The Jersey Side, I thought I’d give it a shot with my friends. For this one, everyone really bought in immediately and completely. This group was humming. We were thinking bloody crime farce, and that’s what we got. When we sorted out relationships, I was playing an older Jewish cancer patient with a fatal diagnosis, Jared was a young Hasidic FBI agent, Krista was a doctor at City Hospital, and J.R. her organ-legging partner in crime, a young Hasidic woman.
I had a Need: Get Even with the Whole Fucking World and was informing on my doctor (Krista) to the FBI agent. Krista and J.R. were partners in crime, and J.R. and the Fed were in the same Hasidic community. We opened strong with me bringing the crimes to the attention of the Federal agent, and he immediately confronted Krista’s doctor. She and her partner in crime panicked and went to a couple of inept Israeli gangsters to get them to take care of the Fed. They botched a kidnapping attempt, and then the two smugglers decided to sell their hot merchandise to some Venezualan gangsters (a much more competent and dangerous crew).
It all came to a head after the Tilt when my character tipped off the Fed to the seedy motel where the smugglers were hiding their goods, and they plus the Israelis all arrived there while the Fed was waiting for them. One Israeli was shot in the leg by the Fed, then brutally murdered with a headshot by the Hasidic smuggler, while the doctor chased after the other Israeli and ran over him with her car. In the end, the Hasidic smuggler went to jail for everything when the doctor pled innocence and turned on her. My character ended up living a long time in miserable pain before the cancer finally did him in, and the Fed wound up jockeying a desk. The doctor had a happy ending and went right back to her life of crime.
Things that went right with this game:
- We were all totally on board and in synch with the tone of the game. It played out just like a movie of this type.
- Everyone was really good about incorporating the elements on the cards, and even looking in the playset to pull out new locations and objects as needed.
- People were eager and able to jump in as NPCs when needed. And we created a couple of very compelling NPCs in the incompetent Israeli gangsters. They were just dangerous enough, and it was awesome to have some available NPCs for slaughtering in Phase Two.
- We figured out pretty quick that the story was really about the two smugglers, and both Jared and I were happy to take a bit of a back seat with our characters. We were catalysts and reactive characters, which was just fine. That helped run the whole bus off the cliff.
Fiasco is a blast and I’d definitely play again. I think I might stick with more straight-up crime sagas, since that seems to be what I enjoy most in the game.
The Jersey Side will be coming out in the Spring as a Playset-of-the-Month, so look for it then. Or track me down at NeonCon or Dreamation and ask me to run it.